About the HP cloud computing strategy

Posted by virtualization.info Staff   |   Thursday, October 21st, 2010   |  

At the beginning of September cloudcomputing.info has been invited by HP to a closed-doors, intimate event for a few influencers in Cupertino. During the two-days mini-conference, very high-profile executives introduced the HP approach to cloud computing, the product and services portfolio, and the go-to-market strategy.

It’s uncommon for a company of this size to pack together in a single room vice presidents, CTOs, and directors to clarify the vision, and answer questions about it for hours, just for a very restricted audience (there were less than 10 people invited, from all around the world). It’s a welcome novel approach considering how fragmented the message can be, buried deep inside tens or even hundreds of press announcements, coming from multiple business units and departments that work on a technology like cloud computing from many different angles.

A few interesting details emerged during the two days, so what follows is a list of things that are worth a report.

The very first thing to report about is how HP position itself at the beginning of the cloud computing era.

Right now, the primary goal doesn’t seem to be the technology provider for cloud infrastructures. Selling hardware and software to build cloud computing infrastructures of course is part of the strategy, but HP doesn’t seem to have set it as its primary goal in this phase. The main goal seems more to be the business partner that assists during the transition to the cloud. So HP has a strong focus on consulting services.
The company has five services: the Discovery Workshop, the Roadmap Service, the Design Service, the Security Service and the CloudStart Solution.

cloudcomputing.info has been particularly impressed by the first one, the Discovery Workshop, which has been briefly demonstrated during the event.
It basically is a consulting day where multiple representatives of a single company are invited at the HP campus in a special training room. The room is filled with giant posters, describing cloud computing from many different perspectives: the 101 definitions, the infrastructure requirements, the business goals, the security risks, the identity management approaches, etc.
The purpose of the day is not to educate a customer about what is cloud computing. The purpose rather is to do a reality check, and be sure that internally, business and technical people are on the same page about what is cloud computing and why the company wants to embrace it.

At the beginning of the demo, it seemed a silly exercise, but after half an hour the value of this approach appeared much more evident. The customer is invited to walk through the posters and openly discuss about them, while HP staff is primarily there to facilitate the discussion. 
HP reports that in many cases the activity reveals profound conflicts in how cloud computing is perceived by different people in the same company, with the workshop becoming the very first opportunity to compare point of views and try to realign expectations and goals. It’s hard to not believe so.

The Discovery Workshop has been particularly impressive not because of the approach, which is probably not unique in the Industry, but for the quality of contents provided, and the knowledge HP demonstrated in describing the current cloud computing trends, challenges and risks.
The presentation has been very objective and, remarkably, completely lacking any specific reference to HP’s portfolio. Not even for a single minute HP used the workshop to pitch its products, and we were told that this is on purpose: for the company, the workshop represents an opportunity to increase awareness and open a discussion with customers, not an opportunity to place sales orders.


cloudcomputing.info didn’t find as convincing the HP Cloud Security Analysis Service.

The company can perform a wide range of assessments, on behalf of the customer, on any 3rd party cloud infrastructure selected by the customer. While this should be done before a customer selects his cloud provider, HP reports that it’s usually requested after the adoption.
This assessments, usually 3 weeks long, may include various activities, from review of compliance policies to infrastructure assessment. HP generates reports and presents findings to customers, providing, if requested, guidance on remediation.

Problem is that these assessments are only available on demand and they seem part of a rather slow, manually driven process. There’s no way for the customer to request some sort of automated assessment, triggered by the occurrence of a specific event. The customer has to recognize the need for an assessment and deal with HP consulting services to book it. Once completed, it can be easily renewed, but it still involves interaction between the parts.
The whole process seems far away from the dynamism required to deal with the rapidly changing infrastructures of cloud computing.

More than that, HP doesn’t rely on any third party, external security provider to assess its own assessment infrastructure. So if the HP tools are compromised, and the customers’ assessments are compromised accordingly, there’s no way to know. The customer has to blindly trust HP without any chance to verify the integrity of the systems.


Another notable presentation has been the one about the new Cloud Maps extensions for Matrix Orchestration Environment (MOE).

MOE is the orchestration framework that HP offers to automate service provisioning inside its BladeSystem Matrix converged/unified infrastructure.
Rather than just provide architecture blueprints to its customers, HP launched at the end of August a number of extensions for MOE called Cloud Maps that completely offload the system architects from infrastructure design duties.
They basically are predefined workflows that leverage MOE to automate the deployment of a few popular software solutions, including Citrix XenApp, Microsoft Exchange/Sharepoint/SQL Server, Oracle RAC/PeopleSoft/Fusion Middleware, Red Hat JBoss, SAP BusinessObjects/NetWeaver, SAS Enterprise BI and even VMware vCloud Director.

Once deployed in MOE, customers find these applications available as business services in the self-service provisioning portal. A Cloud Map tells MOE exactly how to provision blades, networks, storage, operating system instances, and of course application instances to serve a certain amount of users. 
Additionally, the Cloud Maps are developed to scale the service if needed: customers can request more capacity through the portal while MOE adds physical resources behind the scenes.

While Cloud Maps are developed by HP and a third party vendor part of the AllianceONE program, so that customers can’t easily create their own Cloud Maps, they remain great examples of the capabilities and potential of orchestrations frameworks, inspiring the creation of custom, sophisticated workflows for the BladeSystem Matrix.

The Cloud Maps approach greatly simplify the implementation and use of a private cloud infrastructure and it’s a shame that HP only offers them to BladeSystem Matrix customers.
The company stated that Cloud Maps may be available in future also for customers that don’t have this specific hardware. Meanwhile, there are a couple of alternatives available today: the HP Server Automation solution packs and the HP SiteScope solution templates. Of course both are limited compared to Cloud Maps as they cannot control the provisioning of the hardware components.


Overall the impression has been positive: HP seems well positioned to provide guidance and tools to embrace cloud computing, despite the offering could mature even more in few areas, like security.
Another point that seems evident is the fragmentation of HP offering: the plethora of services, and tools that operate or just support the cloud, is impressive (and it’s growing), and in some ways reflects the vastness of the company’s overall portfolio. Without guidance, even just to browse the company’s website, customers can get lost easily. Here the company has to work harder to simplify the message and demonstrate the clarity and transparency that shown during its Discovery Workshop.

Labels: ,

blog comments powered by Disqus

cloudcomputing.info Newest articles
Microsoft loves Red Hat: The business implications

November 18th, 2015

As you may have heard, Microsoft recently announced its “historical” partnership with Red Hat, something that a number of analysts already claimed as a milestone for both companies but especially for…

Red Hat acquires Ansible

October 16th, 2015

Today Red Hat announced that it has signed a definitive agreement to acquire Ansible, provider of an IT automation tool popular especially within the developers’ community.
The acquisition is rumored…

Release: Mirantis OpenStack 7.0

October 2nd, 2015

On September 30, Mirantis announced the availability of version 7.0 of its OpenStack distribution in addition with the long awaited extension of the support from two to three years….

Release: CloudPhysics for vSphere

September 9th, 2015

CloudPhysics, provider of a SaaS performance and capacity analytics solution, announced to have released a new version of its SaaS offering allowing now VMware users to preempt and eliminate…

VMware announcements from its annual VMworld US conference

September 2nd, 2015

During its annual VMworld conference held between August 30 and September 3 in San Fransicso VMware made several announcements. During the keynote on Monday several data center related announcements and…

Microsoft releases 3rd technical preview of Windows Server 2016 and System Center 2016

August 19th, 2015

Microsoft today announced the release of the 3rd technical preview of the next version of its Server Operating System (Windows Server 2016 TP3) and corresponding management software (System Center…

From VirtualizationMatrix comes WhatMatrix – UPDATED

August 19th, 2015

We quoted several times Virtualization Matrix, the website created to compare the capabilities of the various virtualization platforms on the market such VMware, Microsoft and Citrix.
This idea sparked…

Release: Platform9 Managed OpenStack for VMware vSphere

August 19th, 2015

With the news of a $10 million Series B funding round Platform9 announced the GA of its SaaS solution Managed OpenStack for VMware vSphere.
Platform9 solutions leverages a mix…

Platform9 raises $10M series B Funding

August 19th, 2015

OpenStack startup Platform9, provider of a cloud management platform that transforms the on-premises servers infrastructures into private clouds, announced to have closed a $10 million series B funding. The…

Fujitsu joins OpenStack Foundation as Gold Member

August 12th, 2015

Japanese multinational IT and services company Fujitsu, headquartered in Tokyo, has been approved by the Board of Directors of the OpenStack Foundation as Gold Member. Fujitsu has been a…

Release: Red Hat Enterprise Linux OpenStack Platform 7

August 7th, 2015

On August 5, Red Hat has announced the general availability of Red Hat Enterprise Linux OpenStack Platform 7 (RHELOSP), based on OpenStack “Kilo” release.
Red Hat Enterprise Linux OpenStack Platform…

Apprenda raises $24M series D Funding

July 22nd, 2015

Apprenda, founded 2007 and headquartered in Troy, NY, a computer software company provider of Platform-as-a-service (PaaS) software announced that it has closed a $24 million series D funding. The…

Google joined OpenStack Foundation as Corporate Sponsor

July 22nd, 2015

Everyone wants to participate to the OpenStack Foundation, this time is Google which revealed to have signed as Corporate Sponsor. Google is going to focus on integrating containers management…

Red Hat Summit 2015 Wrap-up

June 29th, 2015

Last week, Red Hat held its premiere event in Boston, Massachusetts from June 23 to 26, the Red Hat Summit,  where several announcements have been made.
The summit offered over…

Monthly Archive